Key Takeaways
• The Trojan Ethical Fund applies ethical screening to a capital-preservation, multi-asset approach.
• Ethical investing combines values-based screening with financial objectives.
• Screening, multi-asset and market risks apply, and past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.
• Troy Asset Management is associated with a cautious, preservation-oriented philosophy.
• This article is informational only and does not recommend any fund or security.
Proving Capital Preservation And Ethical Screening Aren’t Mutually Exclusive
Combining two specific investment constraints — a genuine capital preservation objective and a meaningful ethical screening process — creates a fund with a distinctly narrower mandate than either objective pursued independently. The Trojan Ethical Fund takes on exactly this combined challenge, applying Troy Asset Management’s established capital preservation philosophy while layering in specific ethical criteria intended to exclude companies and activities the fund’s ethical framework considers incompatible with its values-based objectives.
Understanding this fund means appreciating both the broader logic of capital preservation investing and the specific additional considerations that come from combining that philosophy with a genuine ethical investment mandate.
What The Fund Actually Does
The Trojan Ethical Fund applies a similar underlying investment philosophy to its sibling Trojan Fund, combining a selection of equities the managers consider high-quality and resilient with allocations to assets like gold and index-linked government bonds intended to provide diversification and protection during periods of market stress. The key distinguishing feature is the application of specific ethical screening criteria to the equity selection process, excluding companies involved in activities the fund’s ethical framework considers incompatible with its stated values, while seeking companies that meet both the fund’s quality and capital preservation criteria and its ethical standards.
This combination means the fund’s investable universe is narrower than either an unconstrained capital preservation fund or a broader ethical fund without the same specific capital preservation objective, reflecting a deliberate choice to serve investors who want both dimensions addressed simultaneously rather than having to choose between a capital preservation-focused fund and an ethically-screened fund as separate, potentially conflicting options.
Why Combining Capital Preservation And Ethical Investing Makes Sense For Some Investors
Several considerations support the appeal of this combined approach for specific investor profiles:
• Values alignment without abandoning defensive positioning. Investors who hold both genuine ethical convictions about how their capital is invested and a preference for capital preservation over aggressive growth strategies can address both priorities through a single fund, rather than needing to compromise on one dimension.
• Ethical screening and quality investing overlap. Companies that pass rigorous ethical screening criteria often also exhibit some of the governance and business practice characteristics associated with the kind of resilient, well-managed businesses that capital preservation strategies typically favor, suggesting some natural overlap between these two selection criteria.
• Reduced exposure to specific tail risks. Excluding certain industries or business practices through ethical screening can, in some cases, also reduce exposure to specific regulatory, reputational, or litigation risks associated with those excluded activities, potentially complementing the fund’s broader capital preservation objective.
• Growing demand for values-aligned defensive strategies. As both ethical investing and capital preservation strategies have each individually grown in popularity, demand has correspondingly grown for funds that can address both priorities simultaneously rather than forcing investors to choose.
The Narrower Universe Trade-Off
Applying both capital preservation criteria and ethical screening simultaneously necessarily narrows the fund’s investable universe more than either constraint would individually. This narrower universe could, in principle, make it more challenging for the fund’s managers to construct a portfolio that fully achieves both objectives simultaneously compared with pursuing either objective without the additional constraint of the other. Understanding this trade-off is important context, since a more constrained investable universe theoretically provides less flexibility for the managers to respond to changing market conditions compared with a fund operating under a single set of criteria.
Understanding What “Ethical” Means For This Specific Fund
As with any ethically-screened fund, understanding the fund’s actual specific criteria matters more than accepting the “ethical” label at face value, since different ethical investment frameworks can define acceptable and excluded activities quite differently. Investors specifically interested in this fund should look closely at its actual stated exclusion criteria and positive selection standards, rather than assuming all ethically-labeled funds apply similar or interchangeable definitions of what constitutes ethical investment.
The Same Capital Preservation Trade-Offs Still Apply
Because this fund maintains the same underlying capital preservation philosophy as its non-ethical sibling fund, it carries the same fundamental trade-off: meaningful allocations to gold, government bonds, and a relatively conservative equity selection mean the fund will typically underperform more aggressive, fully-invested equity strategies during strong bull markets. This trade-off exists independent of, and in addition to, whatever performance effects the fund’s ethical screening criteria might separately introduce.
Assessing Performance Requires Considering Both Dimensions
Evaluating this fund’s performance requires considering both the capital preservation dimension, best assessed across a full market cycle including periods of market stress, and the ethical screening dimension, which introduces its own potential performance divergence depending on how the specific excluded sectors and favored ethical themes perform relative to the broader market during any given period. This dual consideration makes performance evaluation somewhat more complex than for a fund pursuing either objective independently.
Risks Worth Understanding
• Opportunity cost is an expected characteristic of the fund’s capital preservation approach, likely causing underperformance relative to fully-invested equity strategies during strong bull markets.
• Ethical screening narrows the investable universe, potentially limiting exposure to certain sectors or companies regardless of their financial merits or capital preservation characteristics.
• The combination of two specific constraints, capital preservation and ethical screening, could create additional complexity in portfolio construction compared with pursuing either objective independently.
• Gold price volatility and interest rate movements affecting bond holdings carry the same risks present in the broader capital preservation strategy.
• Methodology risk applies given that ethical screening involves subjective judgment, meaning the fund’s specific criteria may differ from other ethically-labeled funds or evolve over time.
• As with any investment fund, capital is at risk, and past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.
Comparing Ethical Capital Preservation Against Standalone Ethical Funds
Investors weighing this fund against a standalone ethical equity fund without the same capital preservation mandate should recognize the genuine trade-off involved. A pure ethical equity fund, unconstrained by capital preservation objectives, may pursue higher growth potential by remaining more fully invested in equities, while this fund deliberately sacrifices some of that growth potential in exchange for the diversification and downside protection that gold and index-linked bonds provide. Investors specifically prioritizing values alignment above all else might prefer a pure ethical equity option, while those wanting both ethical screening and genuine defensive positioning may find this combined approach better suited to their broader objectives.
Conclusion
The Trojan Ethical Fund offers a genuinely distinctive combination of capital preservation investing and ethical screening, serving investors who want both defensive positioning and values-aligned investment criteria addressed within a single strategy. That combination carries clear appeal for a specific investor profile, though it necessarily narrows the fund’s investable universe more than either objective would individually, and it retains the same fundamental trade-off common to all capital preservation strategies: likely underperformance relative to fully-invested equity alternatives during strong bull markets. Understanding both the fund’s specific ethical criteria and its broader capital preservation philosophy is essential for anyone considering whether this combined approach genuinely fits their own investment priorities.






Please wait processing your request...