Following a Court of Appeal loss, HMRC has published Revenue and Customs Brief 9 (2026) setting out a new position on VAT for private education providers. Here is what the brief says, who might have a claim, and the caveats every college should weigh first.
A Court of Appeal ruling has changed the VAT landscape for private colleges — and HMRC has now spelt out how it will respond. Revenue and Customs Brief 9 (2026), published on 2 September, updates HMRC's position on the VAT treatment of education and closely related services supplied by alternative providers of higher and further education. For college finance teams, the practical question is immediate: could your institution have overpaid VAT, and if so, what can you actually do about it?
This explainer walks through what the brief means in plain terms, who is likely to be in scope, and the significant caveats that determine whether a claim is worth making. It is general information, not advice on any particular college's affairs — individual circumstances vary, and professional guidance is essential before acting.
Why the position has changed
The trigger was the decision in St Patrick's International College Ltd & Interactive Manchester Ltd v HMRC, handed down on 6 July 2026. The Court of Appeal held that certain degree-level courses supplied by private colleges — HNCs, HNDs and comparable higher-education programmes — could fall within the VAT exemption for education, because a "typical consumer" would see them as materially similar to courses supplied by exempt universities. Denying the exemption in those circumstances breached the principle of fiscal neutrality.
HMRC had long taken the opposite view. The ruling forced it to update its published guidance, and Brief 9 (2026) is the result. It does not rewrite the law; it reflects the court's decision and explains how affected providers can take matters forward under the normal VAT rules.
What the brief tells providers
At its core, the brief acknowledges the Court of Appeal's conclusion and signals that alternative providers whose supplies genuinely meet the test may reconsider whether VAT they accounted for was correctly charged. Where a provider concludes it overpaid, it can look to the established mechanisms for correcting VAT errors and making repayment claims.
What the brief does not do is declare that every private college is now exempt. HMRC's position is fact-sensitive. A provider must be able to demonstrate that its own courses are comparable, from the student's perspective, to those supplied by universities. That is a real evidential exercise, not a box-ticking one.
The eligibility test in practice
So how do you judge whether your college is likely to be in scope? The starting point is the nature of the courses. The decision concerned higher-education-level qualifications that a prospective student might regard as broadly interchangeable with a university offering. Colleges delivering that kind of provision are the natural candidates.
By contrast, a provider whose courses differ materially in level, content or proposition — short professional courses, for instance, or Training that a student would not equate with a university degree — cannot assume the same treatment. The typical-consumer comparison is the hinge, and it must be applied honestly to your actual offering rather than aspirationally.
Three caveats that can shrink or sink a claim
Even where the eligibility test is met, three well-established limits determine whether a refund is genuinely available.
The first is the four-year cap. Claims to recover overpaid VAT are generally restricted to the last four years, so older overpayments usually fall outside what can be reclaimed. This makes timing important: the longer a college waits, the more of its potential claim slips out of the window.
The second is unjust enrichment. HMRC can resist repaying VAT where the cost was passed on to students in the fees they paid. If Refunding the college would simply enrich the institution rather than the people who actually bore the tax, the claim can be reduced or refused. Colleges will need to think carefully about how their fees were set and who ultimately carried the VAT.
The third is partial exemption. If a provider's supplies become exempt rather than taxable, its ability to recover input VAT on related costs changes too. A shift to exemption is not all upside; it can restrict the VAT a college reclaims on its own expenditure, and the net effect needs to be modelled, not assumed.
What a protective claim is — and why timing matters
Because the four-year cap keeps eroding the recoverable period, and because the law itself may yet be tested further, some colleges may consider a protective claim. This is a claim submitted to preserve a college's position within the time limits, pending certainty about the law, rather than an assertion that a refund is guaranteed.
Submitting a protective claim does not oblige HMRC to pay; it keeps the door open while the position is worked through. Given that the underlying law could still change — commentators expect HMRC may seek permission to appeal to the Supreme Court, though no appeal is confirmed — a protective approach can be a way of managing that uncertainty. Whether it is the right step for any particular college depends entirely on its facts and should be discussed with a VAT adviser.
A sensible checklist for finance teams
Colleges weighing their Options can start with a few practical questions. Do our courses plausibly meet the typical-consumer comparison with university provision? Over what period did we account for VAT that might have been exempt, and how much falls within the last four years? Were fees set VAT-inclusive, and would repayment raise unjust-enrichment issues? How would a move to exemption affect our input VAT recovery? And should we consider a protective claim now to preserve our position?
Good record-keeping underpins all of this. Any claim will need evidence about the courses supplied, the VAT accounted for and the way fees were charged.
The bottom line
Revenue and Customs Brief 9 (2026) opens a real opportunity for well-placed private colleges, but it is an opportunity hedged with conditions. Eligibility depends on the facts, the four-year cap limits how far back claims reach, unjust enrichment and partial exemption can reduce the value, and the law may not be fully settled. The prudent path is to assess your own position against the current HMRC guidance on GOV.UK and take professional advice before committing to a claim — rather than assuming a refund is automatically owed.






Please wait processing your request...