After losing in the Court of Appeal over VAT on courses supplied by private colleges, HMRC has updated its published position — but the fight may not be finished. Commentators expect the tax authority to weigh an appeal to the Supreme Court.
When the Court of Appeal handed down its decision in St Patrick's International College Ltd & Interactive Manchester Ltd v HMRC on 6 July 2026, it did more than resolve one dispute about VAT. It exposed a fault line running through the law on how the education exemption applies to alternative providers of higher and further education — and it did so in a way that leaves the final destination of the argument genuinely uncertain. HMRC has now updated its guidance in Revenue and Customs Brief 9 (2026), published on 2 September, but the way the court reached its conclusion means a further chapter, potentially in the Supreme Court, cannot be ruled out.
This matters because the ruling was not a clean loss for HMRC on the merits. It was a defeat driven by precedent — and that distinction is exactly what could push the case up to the highest court in the land.
A defeat built on precedent, not agreement
The substantive question was whether private colleges without university status could benefit from the VAT exemption for education under Article 132(1)(i) of the Principal VAT Directive, which extends to organisations "recognised as having similar objects" to public educational bodies. The Court of Appeal decided they could, because the similarity had to be judged from the "typical consumer's" point of view under the principle of fiscal neutrality — and degree-level HNC and HND courses looked, to a prospective student, much like university courses.
But the court did not say this was self-evidently right. It held that it was bound by the earlier LIFE Services authority on the typical-consumer test. Where a previous court had already worked through the same Court of Justice case law, a later court had to follow it. In other words, the colleges won because of how the doctrine of precedent operates, not because the Court of Appeal was persuaded from first principles.
The "considerable force" that changes everything
The clearest signal came from Lord Justice Miles, who recorded that there was "considerable force" in HMRC's substantive arguments while declining to express a concluded view on them. For a losing party, that is an unusually inviting remark. It suggests that a higher court, not bound in the same way by the earlier decision, might reach a different answer.
That is the crux of why an appeal is being talked about. When a judgment turns on a binding precedent that the deciding judge appears to doubt, the natural route is to ask a court with the power to revisit that precedent. The Supreme Court is not bound by the Court of Appeal's earlier rulings and could, in principle, re-examine the whole approach to the typical-consumer test.
What the commentators expect
Tax practitioners have been quick to read the runes. The prevailing view among VAT commentators is that HMRC is likely to seek permission to appeal to the Supreme Court, precisely because the substantive law was left open and the financial and policy implications are wide. Some describe a further appeal as highly likely given the "considerable force" observation.
It is important to be precise, however. As of early September 2026, no appeal has been confirmed. HMRC has updated its guidance and acknowledged the current state of the law, but it has not publicly committed to taking the case further. The realistic position is that an appeal is anticipated but not certain — which is why the question is best framed as one HMRC could face, rather than one already under way.
Why HMRC has strong reasons to press on
Several factors point towards HMRC wanting a definitive answer. First, the decision affects a whole category of suppliers, not a single college, so the revenue and policy consequences extend well beyond the parties. Second, the exemption's boundaries — how far the typical-consumer test can stretch the phrase "similar objects" — are a matter of general importance that a Supreme Court ruling could settle for years. Third, HMRC's substantive arguments were not rejected on their merits; they were left standing, which gives the authority something to build on.
Against that, litigation carries risk and cost, and the Supreme Court might simply confirm the Court of Appeal's approach. But where the law has been left unsettled by a decision resting on contested precedent, the incentive to seek certainty is real.
A Brexit dimension in the background
There is a further complication that makes the law's future direction harder to predict. The case concerned periods when EU law, including the Principal VAT Directive and the Court of Justice authorities behind the typical-consumer test, applied directly. The Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act 2023 changed the status of EU-derived law in the UK, including the supremacy principle. How the reasoning in St Patrick's translates to more recent and future periods is itself a live question — one more reason the ultimate legal position may need higher-court clarification.
What providers and observers should watch
For alternative providers, the practical message is one of alert caution. The current law favours well-placed colleges, but it sits on foundations that a Supreme Court appeal could shift. Providers considering their VAT position — including any protective claims to preserve their rights within the usual time limits — will want to Factor in the possibility that the law changes again.
The key milestones to watch are whether HMRC applies for permission to appeal, whether permission is granted, and how any subsequent hearing frames the typical-consumer test. Until then, the Court of Appeal's decision governs, and HMRC's updated brief reflects it.
An unfinished story
What makes this episode compelling is that a case can be won and still feel unresolved. The colleges secured a favourable ruling, HMRC has adjusted its published stance, and yet the judge's own words hint that the substantive argument remains open. Whether HMRC ultimately walks into a Supreme Court battle depends on decisions not yet taken. For anyone with a stake in how VAT applies to alternative higher education, the sensible course is to treat the current position as settled for now — but not necessarily for good — and to check GOV.UK and take professional advice as the picture develops.






Please wait processing your request...