Revenue and Customs Brief 9 (2026) updates HMRC's VAT position for alternative higher and further education providers after a Court of Appeal defeat. It sets out how affected colleges might claim overpaid VAT — subject to the four-year cap and unjust enrichment.

HMRC does not update its published position lightly, so the arrival of Revenue and Customs Brief 9 (2026) on 2 September 2026 is a signal worth reading carefully. The brief responds to a Court of Appeal defeat and revises HMRC's stance on the VAT Liability of education supplied by alternative providers of higher and further education. For colleges that have been charging VAT on degree-level courses, it opens the door — cautiously — to reclaiming tax they may not have needed to pay. But the door leads to a process, not a payout, and the brief is careful to spell out the conditions.

Inside Revenue and Customs Brief 9 (2026)

The brief's function is to tell taxpayers and advisers how HMRC now sees the law following the Court of Appeal's ruling. It confirms that HMRC is updating its position on when supplies of education (and closely related goods and services) by alternative providers can be exempt from VAT, and it points affected providers towards the possibility of making claims for VAT they have overpaid.

Crucially, the brief frames this as an update to HMRC's position rather than a wholesale surrender. It does not declare that every alternative provider's courses are now exempt. Instead it acknowledges the effect of the judgment and sets out the framework within which claims can be considered — including the standard limits that apply to any VAT repayment claim.

How the door opened: the St Patrick's ruling

The brief exists because of St Patrick's International College Ltd & Interactive Manchester Ltd v HMRC ([2026] EWCA Civ 852), decided on 6 July 2026 and heard alongside a related appeal by London College of Contemporary Arts. The Court of Appeal allowed the providers' appeal, finding that their degree-level courses were sufficiently similar, from the typical consumer's point of view, to courses supplied by exempt universities. Taxing the alternative providers' supplies while exempting comparable university courses breached fiscal neutrality.

That is the legal foundation on which any claim now rests. Providers whose courses genuinely resemble exempt university provision — in level, content and how a typical student would view them — are the ones the reasoning is most likely to help.

Making a claim: the four-year cap

The first practical constraint is time. A claim to recover overpaid output VAT is generally subject to a four-year cap, meaning a provider can usually reclaim VAT accounted for only in the four years before the claim is made. Overpayments older than that window are typically lost.

This single rule drives much of the urgency that advisers are now communicating to the sector. Because the four-year period rolls forward continuously, every quarter that passes without a claim can push older, recoverable VAT out of reach. For providers weighing whether to act, the cap is a reason to review their position promptly rather than wait to see how the wider legal picture develops — a live consideration given that HMRC may yet seek to challenge the decision further.

The unjust enrichment hurdle

The second constraint is more subtle. Even where a provider has overpaid VAT and is within time, HMRC may resist a refund on the ground of unjust enrichment. The principle is that a repayment should not leave a Business better off at the expense of the people who actually bore the tax.

If a college charged its students a VAT-inclusive price and effectively passed the tax on to them, HMRC may argue that Refunding the VAT to the college — rather than to the students who paid it — would unjustly enrich the college. Whether that argument succeeds, and to what extent, depends on the commercial facts: how prices were set, who bore the economic burden, and whether the provider absorbed the VAT itself. It is a fact-sensitive issue that can reduce or complicate a claim, and it is one reason two providers in apparently similar positions can end up with very different outcomes.

No blanket entitlement

Running through the brief is a clear message: this is not an automatic refund for the whole sector. Entitlement depends on the facts of each provider and each course. A provider delivering degree-level HNC or HND programmes closely comparable to university courses stands on very different ground from one offering short or non-degree courses that a typical student would not see as interchangeable with university provision.

HMRC's position, as the brief sets out, is that affected alternative providers may consider making claims subject to the normal rules — not that they are all entitled to succeed. Providers should therefore test their own circumstances against the reasoning in the judgment before assuming the decision applies to them.

Practical steps for affected colleges

For a provider that thinks it may be within scope, the sensible sequence is clear. Start by mapping the course portfolio against the typical consumer test the court applied, distinguishing degree-level provision comparable to universities from other courses. Quantify the potentially recoverable VAT within the four-year window. Consider how the VAT was borne commercially, because that will shape any unjust enrichment analysis. Then decide, with advice, whether to submit a claim now or lodge a protective claim to preserve position while the law settles.

Good record-keeping underpins all of this. A claim will need evidence of the supplies made, the VAT accounted for and the periods involved, so assembling that documentation early is time well spent. It is also worth engaging advisers before submitting anything, because how a claim is framed and supported can influence how HMRC responds to it.

A measured opening, not a windfall

Revenue and Customs Brief 9 (2026) is a meaningful development for alternative education providers, and for some it will translate into real VAT recovery. But it is written in the language of conditions rather than concessions: eligibility turns on the facts, claims are bounded by the four-year cap, and unjust enrichment may stand in the way. Because so much depends on individual circumstances, affected providers should read the brief in full on GOV.UK and take professional advice before acting rather than treating the ruling as a guaranteed refund.