HMRC's systems for Self Assessment and Making Tax Digital lean heavily on the tax return, so a former sole trader or landlord who simply stops filing can leave HMRC working from an out-of-date picture.

Closing a small Business or ending a letting arrangement can feel like the end of the paperwork as well. HMRC's own processes suggest otherwise. Whether someone is written to about Making Tax Digital, for example, depends on what their Self Assessment return shows, and HMRC's wider records are shaped by the returns people send in.

That makes the coming months significant for anyone whose circumstances have changed. Paper returns for 2025-26 must reach HMRC by 11:59pm on Saturday 31 October 2026, and online returns are due by 11:59pm on Sunday 31 January 2027. Those who have stopped trading or letting and are unsure whether a 2025-26 return is still required may wish to contact HMRC or check GOV.UK to confirm their position before either date.

How HMRC uses the return to decide what comes next

The clearest example of the return driving HMRC's decisions is Making Tax Digital for Income Tax. HMRC's eligibility guidance says it reviews the Self Assessment return each year and writes to people whose income is over the relevant threshold. The threshold is £50,000, based on 2024-25 income, for those required to join from 6 April 2026; £30,000, based on 2025-26 income, from 6 April 2027; and £20,000, based on 2026-27 income, from 6 April 2028.

The test uses what HMRC calls qualifying income, which its 5 October 2026 release defines as gross income from self-employment and property, before tax allowances or expenses. The same release says that to be within scope, a person must be registered for Self Assessment and have submitted a tax return within the last two years. Exemptions exist for digitally excluded people.

HMRC is also taking a more active role in enrolment. Its August 2026 release said that from September 2026 it would begin signing up customers who had not signed up. Against that backdrop, the information on a person's latest return carries real weight. A 2025-26 return is the basis for the £30,000 test that applies from April 2027.

What skipping a required return can cost

Where a return is required and is not filed on time, HMRC's penalty regime applies. Its guidance sets an initial £100 penalty for a late return. After three months, HMRC can charge £10 a day up to a maximum of £900. After six months, a further penalty of 5% of the tax due or £300, whichever is greater, applies, and the same again after 12 months.

Those amounts are separate from any late payment penalties, which HMRC sets at 5% of unpaid tax at 30 days, six months and 12 months, plus interest. HMRC says penalties can be appealed where there is a reasonable excuse.

The Making Tax Digital regime has its own penalty structure. HMRC says points-based penalties for late quarterly updates start from 6 April 2027, with a £200 fixed penalty after four points. It will not apply penalty points for late quarterly updates during the 2026-27 tax year, although updates must still be sent before the tax return and late tax return penalties continue to apply.

Small sums, allowances and the registration picture

Not every reduction in activity means leaving Self Assessment entirely, and not every small income stream brings someone into it. HMRC's September 2026 announcement on its improved registration service restated, in the context of Self Assessment registration, a £1,000 trading allowance and a £2,500 threshold for untaxed income.

The scale of small-scale letting is considerable. HMRC's property rental income statistics, published on 28 August 2026, show that 2.88 million unincorporated landlords declared rental income in 2024-25, and that 1.3 million of them, or 45%, had property income of £10,000 or less.

The registration side of the system has also become quicker. HMRC says 640,000 people registered for Self Assessment in the 12 months to 31 March 2026, and that online registration produces a Unique Taxpayer Reference within 72 hours, compared with 15 days by post. The registration deadline for 2025-26, 5 October 2026, has passed. HMRC says registering after that date could lead to a penalty, with a filing deadline three months from the date on its letter and any tax still due by 31 January 2027.

HMRC's guidance on genuine contact, updated on 29 September 2026, explains that it may use several channels together, partly because they "are the contact details HMRC has for you". That guidance is a reminder that HMRC's correspondence goes to the details it holds. Those who receive contact they are unsure about can check it against HMRC's scam guidance, and suspicious emails can be reported to [email protected].

The bottom line

HMRC's processes for both Self Assessment and Making Tax Digital draw on the information in tax returns. Its eligibility guidance says it reviews the return each year and writes to people over the threshold, and its qualifying income test looks at gross self-employment and property income.

For anyone who has stopped trading or renting, the practical question is whether HMRC's records still reflect a live business or letting. Where a return is required and missed, HMRC's late filing penalties start at £100 and can rise to £900 in daily charges alone, before percentage-based penalties apply.

With paper returns due on 31 October and online returns on 31 January 2027, those whose circumstances have changed can check the position on GOV.UK or with HMRC directly.