Recruiter Hays (LSE:HAS) reported a smaller decline in first-quarter net fees and healthy growth in North America and Asia, but weakness in Germany and the UK and a sluggish permanent hiring market weighed on the shares.

Hays, the specialist recruitment group, released its first-quarter trading statement on 12 October, covering the three months to 30 September 2026. The numbers pointed to an improving trend: like-for-like net fees fell by around 3%, a marked improvement on the 8% decline recorded in the same quarter a year earlier. On a reported basis, which includes currency effects, fees were down about 5%, and the September exit rate showed a fall of roughly 2%.

Despite the narrower decline, which was better than many forecasts had pencilled in, the shares fell by around 10% during trading on 12 October. The reaction suggests investors had hoped for clearer evidence that a recovery in the group's largest markets was taking hold, rather than simply a slower rate of contraction.

A tale of two markets

The regional picture was mixed. In Germany, historically one of the group's most important profit centres, like-for-like fees declined by about 6%, while the UK and Ireland business was down roughly 5%. Both markets have been hampered by cautious corporate hiring and subdued economic growth.

Elsewhere, momentum was considerably firmer. Fees in the United States rose by around 8%, helped in part by construction recruitment linked to data centre and energy projects. Canada grew by about 12%, China by around 27% and Japan by roughly 2%. The contrast underlines how Hays' fortunes are increasingly tied to a handful of growth markets while its larger European operations remain under pressure.

By business line, permanent recruitment remained the weaker area, with fees down around 7% like-for-like. Temporary and contracting fees, which tend to be more resilient during downturns, slipped by about 1%. That pattern is consistent with the group's guidance in April, when it said it expected greater resilience in temp and contracting than in permanent placements.

Restructuring and cost savings

Under chief executive Mark Dearnley, Hays has been pursuing a substantial restructuring programme. The company has secured around £50m of annualised structural cost savings, ahead of its original timetable, and plans to concentrate on 16 core markets. In April it had said it was targeting £45m of annual savings by its 2029 financial year, so the programme appears to have been accelerated.

For the year to 30 June 2026, operating profit before one-off items was reported at around £48.6m, a modest increase on the previous year. However, one-off charges of roughly £89.6m were taken, and the group has indicated that further one-off costs will be incurred in the current financial year as the restructuring continues. The balance sheet remains in net cash, at about £20.1m at the end of June, supported by healthy cash conversion, and the final dividend was held at 0.29p per share.

What the market is watching

Hays (LSE:HAS) did not issue formal profit guidance alongside the update. A sustained recovery in earnings will likely depend on three factors: a revival in permanent hiring, a stabilisation of temporary volumes in Germany, and the durability of growth in the United States. The success of the cost programme in delivering lasting savings, rather than one-off reductions, is also likely to be central to sentiment.

The shares have been among the weaker performers in the FTSE 250 over the past year, reflecting a prolonged downturn across the global recruitment industry that has also affected rivals such as PageGroup and Robert Walters. Investors will be looking to the next quarterly update for confirmation that the narrowing decline in fees is turning into growth.