A REIT buying its own shares

Custodian Property Income REIT (LSE:CREI) has been repurchasing its own shares through September 2026, and its announcements say why that can make sense: the shares have been trading below the value of the property portfolio behind them. The question is how Buybacks fit alongside the company's lending limits, Dividend commitment and plans to grow.

A diversified regional property portfolio

Custodian Property Income REIT, listed on the Main Market of the London Stock Exchange under the code CREI, owns a portfolio of 172 UK properties valued at £671.6 million. Its focus is smaller regional Assets let to a broad range of tenants. According to the company, industrial property makes up 50% of the portfolio by value, retail warehouses 21%, other uses such as car showrooms and drive-throughs 15%, offices 8% and high street retail 6%. The portfolio is run by an Investment manager whose managing director is Richard Shepherd-Cross, and the company describes its approach as hands-on asset management aimed at earnings-accretive investment in existing buildings and sustainable dividend growth.

The latest buyback and AGM

On 24 September 2026, the company reported that it had bought 100,000 shares on 23 September at 81.0p each, a 17.8% discount to dividend-adjusted net asset value. The purchase was made under an irrevocable, non-discretionary programme first announced on 17 July 2025 and extended on 11 June 2026, with Deutsche Bank executing purchases independently during closed periods. After the purchase, the company held 6,895,732 shares in treasury and had 488,217,079 shares in issue excluding treasury. Earlier buyback notices had been issued on 2, 11 and 16 September 2026 as well. At the Annual General Meeting on 17 September 2026, all 14 resolutions passed on a poll, including the authority to make market purchases, which received 99.94% support.

Portfolio performance and finances

The company's quarterly update of 2 September 2026 reported net asset value of £489.0 million, or 100.0p per share, at 30 June 2026, compared with 99.7p at 31 March, and a quarterly NAV total return of 1.8%. Estimated rental value increased to £56.1 million, while passing rent was £49.0 million, leaving reversionary potential of 15%. Like-for-like rental values rose 1.0% in the quarter. Asset management included a 7.5-year Lease extension with Matalan in Leicester, a 20-year Burger King letting in Carlisle and rent reviews at properties in Cannock and Shrewsbury that lifted rents by 22% and 23% respectively.

Net gearing was 26.1% loan-to-value. Borrowings of £185.0 million had a weighted average cost of 4.1%, with £120 million fixed at an average 3.3% and £65 million variable at 5.5%. The company paid a 1.5p dividend for the quarter, which it said was fully covered by EPRA earnings, and targets at least 6.0p for the year to March 2027.

Risks to watch

Shepherd-Cross acknowledged "persistent discounts to NAV" across the sector even as he described the occupier market as "extremely resilient". Buybacks absorb cash that could otherwise reduce borrowing or fund refurbishment, and the variable-rate Debt keeps the company exposed to Interest Rate movements. Valuations were broadly flat in the quarter, with a like-for-like increase of only 0.1%, so recent NAV progress has come largely from income rather than Capital growth. Office and high street exposure, energy efficiency requirements ahead of 2031, and the company's stated interest in selective corporate acquisitions are further areas to monitor.

Conclusion

Custodian Property Income REIT is buying back shares because, on its own reported figures, they trade at a meaningful discount to net asset value, most recently 17.8% on 23 September 2026. The programme is relatively small against a £489.0 million NAV, and the company reports that gearing remains moderate and its dividend covered, which suggests buybacks are a supplement to, rather than a replacement for, its asset management strategy.