Palace Capital (LSE:PCA) and Cardiff Property (LSE:CDFF) are two of the smallest property companies in the FTSE Fledgling, the index for UK Main Market companies too small for the FTSE All-Share. Both are debt-free, both hold large cash balances relative to their size, and both are using share buybacks. That makes the value of their remaining property the central question for each.

The difference lies in direction. Palace Capital is in an orderly realisation, selling Assets and returning cash, so its Net Asset Value (NAV) is effectively a running estimate of what shareholders may eventually receive. Cardiff Property is a long-established Thames Valley investor that is still running its portfolio, though it too sold a significant asset in 2026.

Why asset values matter more for small property companies

NAV is the value of a company's assets, mainly property and cash, minus its liabilities, divided by the number of shares. For property companies it rests on independent valuations, which are estimates rather than prices achieved.

Two tests show whether those valuations are credible. The first is whether assets sell close to book value. The second is whether the share price trades near NAV or at a discount, which signals doubt about values, costs or timing. Both companies offer evidence on each.

Indicative share prices on 25 September 2026 were 190p for Palace Capital and 2,750p for Cardiff Property. These are used here only to illustrate discounts.

Palace Capital: realising the portfolio

Palace Capital's website states that the company is "focused on returning cash to shareholders". Its interim results for the six months to 31 March 2026, published on 11 June, show how far that process has gone.

NAV per share fell 14% to 210p from 244p at 30 September 2025, with total NAV of £42.5m. The remaining portfolio of five properties was valued at £31.3m, a like-for-like fall of 16%. By value it was 59% offices, 30% leisure and 11% residential. The Sol leisure complex in Northampton was marked down to £9.6m from £12.8m.

Disposals tell a more mixed story. Broad Street Plaza in Halifax sold in February 2026 for £9.9m, an 8.7% premium to its September 2025 valuation. Elsewhere, a sale of Imperial Court in Leamington Spa was withdrawn, and The Forum in Exeter was under offer subject to vacant possession and planning risk.

Cash rose to £12.8m at 31 March, and the company has no debt. It reported an IFRS loss before tax of £5.4m, mainly reflecting the revaluation, and an adjusted loss of £0.1m. Gross rental income fell to £2.0m from £3.1m as assets were sold.

Capital returns have shifted from dividends to buybacks. An earlier tender offer returned £21.2m. The board said the best use of its remaining £6.9m of distributable reserves was an on-market buyback, and on 30 June it launched a programme for up to 3,633,880 shares, running until 9 October 2026 or the next AGM. That is roughly 18% of the 20.2m diluted shares used in the NAV calculation.

Governance has also changed. Christian Kappelhoff-Wulff joined the board as non-executive chairman on 23 January 2026, and the interim report said a review of the previous board's conduct was continuing.

Cardiff Property: cash-rich and conservative

Cardiff Property invests in and develops property in the Thames Valley, west of London and near Heathrow, and owns 47.62% of the Campmoss Property Company joint venture. Its half-year report to 31 March 2026, published on 1 May, showed profit before tax of £726,000 against £756,000 a year earlier.

Net assets were £30.68m, or £30.92 per share, up from £29.72. The company has zero gearing. It held £10.52m in cash plus £4.35m in term deposits, together nearly half of net assets.

The portfolio under management was valued at about £23m, split 42.5% retail, 38.1% office and care home, 13.0% residential and 6.4% Business units. Rental income was £380,000 and financial income was £313,000, showing how much of the company's Earnings now come from interest on cash.

After the period end, Cardiff completed the sale of The Priory in Burnham for £6.2m at the end of April 2026. The interim Dividend was raised by a third to 10.0p, paid on 25 June 2026.

Cardiff bought back 12,220 shares for £319,000 in the half, an average of about £26.10 per share, below its reported NAV. Chairman J Richard Wollenberg said the Thames Valley market "indicated signs of recovery" early in the period, but warned of headwinds including the possibility of higher interest rates.

Comparing the two balance sheets

On our reading, Palace Capital's key test is whether it can turn a £31.3m portfolio into cash near book value. Its March Revaluation was steep, which reduces the risk of disappointment but shows how much values had already fallen.

Cardiff's test is different. With so much cash, much of its NAV is not exposed to property valuation at all. The question is whether the board redeploys cash into property, keeps buying back shares or holds it.

Using those 25 September prices, Palace Capital traded about 10% below its March NAV and Cardiff about 11% below. These discounts are indicative only, because each NAV is almost six months old and Palace's buyback reduces the share count.

Risks and dates to watch

For Palace Capital, the risks are further valuation falls on offices and leisure, failed or delayed sales such as The Forum, and running costs eating into a shrinking asset base. Its buyback authority runs until 9 October 2026 or the next AGM, and updates appear in its regulatory announcements.

For Cardiff, the risks are low liquidity, concentration on one region and the effect of interest rates on both property values and deposit income. The company's recent pattern, visible on its announcement history, has been to publish full-year results in late November.

What the numbers say

Palace Capital (LSE:PCA) and Cardiff Property (LSE:CDFF) put property asset values in the spotlight because both are small, debt-free companies whose share prices hinge on how much their buildings and cash are really worth. One is testing that by selling; the other is holding a conservative balance sheet. Neither set of figures can show how the next valuation or sale will turn out.