The Office of Rail and Road has rejected three applications to run new open access services on the West Coast Main Line, including a proposal from First Rail Stirling, which trades as Lumo, for trains between Rochdale and London Euston. The release was issued by the regulator and carried under the market code of FirstGroup (LSE:FGP); it is not a statement by FirstGroup.

What was announced

The announcement, dated 8 October 2026, is a press release from the Office of Rail and Road (ORR), which describes itself as "the independent safety and economic regulator for Britain's railways". Although it appears under the code of FirstGroup (LSE:FGP), it was not issued by FirstGroup, contains no comment from the company and does not state any financial impact on FirstGroup.

ORR said it had rejected three applications for new train services on the West Coast Main Line between London Euston and destinations in the north. According to the notes to the release, First Rail Stirling (Lumo) had sought rights for four daily return services between Rochdale and London Euston on weekdays and Saturdays, and three daily return services on Sundays. Wrexham, Shropshire & Midlands Railway Company (WSMR) had applied for four daily return services between Wrexham General and London Euston, comprising three firm rights and one contingent right. Avanti West Coast had sought one new weekday and one new Saturday return service between Blackpool North and London Euston.

The regulator's reasoning

ORR concluded that adding trains to the route would be likely to increase delays and cancellations. It said the capacity and performance of the southern section of the West Coast Main Line had not materially changed since it rejected similar applications in July 2025. "An external review commissioned by ORR also supported this conclusion," the release stated. The regulator explained that gaps in the timetable are needed to allow trains to recover from disruption, and that filling those gaps with new services would reduce resilience.

Stephanie Tobyn, ORR's director of strategy, policy and reform, said: "New services, destinations and greater choice can bring real benefits for passengers and communities. But the West Coast Main Line is already under significant pressure, with performance reflecting limited resilience on a heavily used part of the rail network." She added that the regulator's "detailed analysis has shown that adding more trains to the current timetable would reduce the ability to recover when disruption occurs, increasing the risk of delays spreading and making reliability of the network worse for all passengers."

The one approval

ORR did approve one element of Avanti West Coast's application. Avanti's weekday 19:29 Chester to London Euston service, which already runs as an empty coaching stock movement with a crew on board, has been granted access to carry passengers until December 2030. Because the train already operates, the regulator noted that the decision does not add an extra train to the route.

Background and what to watch next

The notes to the release recall that in July 2025 ORR rejected applications from WSMR, Lumo NW and Virgin Trains, finding that "there was insufficient capacity to introduce any of the proposed services" and that they would have had a detrimental impact on performance. The latest decision therefore extends the regulator's position on the southern part of the line for a further round of applications.

FirstGroup did not issue its own response in this announcement, and the release gives no indication of whether First Rail Stirling intends to pursue the Rochdale proposal in another form. No financial figures relating to the application were disclosed. Any future change in capacity or performance on the southern West Coast Main Line would be relevant to further applications, but ORR did not set out a timetable for reconsideration. Readers seeking detail can consult ORR's published decision and its open access guidance, both referenced in the release.