FirstGroup (LSE:FGP) has long been one of the big names behind Britain's franchised railways. That era is closing. South Western Railway moved into public ownership in May 2025, Great Western Railway follows on 13 December 2026, and the West Coast Partnership, which runs Avanti West Coast, is expected to transfer around the end of the 2027 financial year. The fee income FirstGroup earned for running these networks for the Department for Transport will disappear within about 18 months.

Management's answer is to put most of its money into buses and coaches. First Bus is now the group's largest division by revenue, and about £140m of net Investment is planned for it in the 2027 financial year, mainly to electrify the fleet with government co-funding. Buses offer a growing pool of franchised and contracted work, coach firms can be bought and bolted on, and none of it depends on how Whitehall restructures the railways.

Rail has not been dropped: open access operators Lumo and Hull Trains are expanding, and in May 2026 the group began running the London Overground. But FirstGroup is becoming a road transport operator with a capital-light rail Business attached.

How the business makes money

First Bus has three strands: regional networks earning fares and public funding; First Bus London, running red bus routes under TfL contracts, with FY 2026 its first full year in the group; and a business and coach arm doing private hire, rail replacement and contract work. The company expects about £1bn of regional bus Revenue to move under franchising, where authorities set routes and fares, over five years.

First Rail comprises open access, where Lumo and Hull Trains take full revenue risk; fees from the remaining DfT contracts; and Rail Services, including Delay Repay processing and consultancy. The London Overground concession is a management contract, with TfL keeping revenue risk.

Recent performance

Results for the year to 28 March 2026, published on 18 June 2026, showed adjusted revenue up 25% to £1,716m. London buses drove most of the increase. Adjusted operating profit fell slightly, from £222.8m to £219.4m, and statutory profit before tax dropped from £164.9m to £156.7m. Adjusted Earnings Per Share still rose from 19.4p to 20.3p, helped by a completed £50m share buyback. The full-year Dividend went up from 6.5p to 7.2p.

First Bus revenue rose to £1,443.6m and its adjusted operating profit grew 7% to £102.8m. The Margin fell from 8.9% to 7.1%, reflecting lower-margin London contracts, about £26m less fare funding and £15m of extra employer National Insurance. Regional passenger journeys fell 3% as the national fare cap moved to £3. Business and coach revenue rose 28% to £230.1m.

First Rail's adjusted operating profit fell from £148.8m to £129.9m. The net fees attributable to FirstGroup from DfT contracts dropped to £29.3m, down from £39.0m. Open access revenue rose 3% to £109.3m, and Lumo's services were extended to Glasgow in December 2025.

Strategy and catalysts

Lumo's Stirling-to-London service is ramping up after £6.3m of mobilisation costs, and each of the planned Stirling and Carmarthen routes is expected to bring in about £50m of annual revenue at mid-teens margins once established. The Carmarthen service is expected to start in December 2027. A roughly £500m Lease with Hitachi covers fourteen new trains, and applications for about one billion extra annual seat miles sit with the regulator.

On the bus side, First Bus signed the first West Yorkshire Franchise contracts in September 2026, covering services from its Bramley and Huddersfield depots from spring 2027. The coach business keeps buying smaller operators, with Wilfreda Beehive and Eagles Coaches added after the year end. In August 2026 the group sold its Mistral Data software unit to Tracsis for £48m, for a business earning about £4m of operating profit.

Management expects about £400m of free Cash Flow over three years. That includes around £90m of cash released as the GWR and West Coast contracts wind down. A further £100m buyback is under way.

Valuation talking points

At about 177p in late September 2026, the shares trade at roughly 8.7 times FY 2026 adjusted EPS, with a trailing Dividend Yield of around 4%. The Market Value is a little over £900m. Year-end adjusted net Debt was a modest £138m, and the pension schemes were in a small net surplus of £19.9m.

The debate centres on earnings once DfT fees have gone. Management has warned that the GWR handover alone will cut adjusted operating profit by about £15m in FY 2027, and the West Coast transfer will reduce it further. Supporters argue buybacks, open access growth and bus gains can compensate; sceptics say thin bus margins and policy-dependent earnings merit a low multiple.

The bull case

  • Strong cash generation, with about £400m of free cash flow guided over three years, supports Buybacks and a progressive dividend while debt stays low.
  • Open access rail makes high returns and has clear growth ahead, including Stirling, Carmarthen, ten-car Lumo trains from FY 2029 and pending track access applications.
  • Bus franchising in Manchester, West Yorkshire and elsewhere could make returns lower but more predictable, which may justify a higher rating.
  • Electrification and third-party depot charging could, over time, reduce running costs and open up extra revenue.

The bear case

  • DfT fee income is going away. GWR and West Coast together have provided a meaningful share of rail profit, and replacing that is not guaranteed.
  • Great British Railways may still limit open access track rights, and the company lists this among its principal risks.
  • Bus margins fell to 7.1% in FY 2026, and weaker fare funding, higher labour costs and falling regional passenger numbers could keep them under pressure.
  • Heavy electrification spending, about £140m in FY 2027 alone, carries execution risk and relies on continued government co-funding.

The bottom line

FirstGroup's pivot to buses reflects a lack of choice on the railways. The DfT contracts that once defined it are being taken back, and management is reinvesting in bus fleets, coach acquisitions and open access routes it controls. FY 2026 showed earnings can hold steady against a difficult policy backdrop.

For investors, the main questions are how quickly open access and bus profits can Fill the gap left by GWR and Avanti, and whether Great British Railways leaves room for private operators on the tracks. The share price already reflects plenty of caution; the next two years of transition will decide which way the rating moves.